Are Working Landscapes Desirable?

Natural Resources

Economic Development

Government Presence

Neighbor vs. Neighbor

Public vs. Private

Urban Sprawl


Tourism is part of our culture and is often our chief connection to our natural surroundings. A landscape is like a canoe. It can hold only so many people before it sinks. So how can tourism be a part of a working landscape? To find an answer, the problems associated with tourism must be explored. Let's look at how tourism affects a landscape’s economic potential, ecological makeup, and social needs.

Tourism can benefit a community financially. It provides business opportunities and jobs (camp grounds, hotels, restaurants, gas stations). Some of the money generated from tourism is used for environmental maintenance; however, maintenance of a landscape that attracts tourists can be expensive because it involves cleaning up after the visitors. That means dealing with air and water pollution, repairing animal habitat, and monitoring biodiversity.

Tourism can devastate the ecology of a landscape. There is a broad range of problems. First, consider why landscapes are tourist attractions. Some landscapes are scenic and special because people haven't interacted with them. Tourism brings human interaction, which may bring some negatives. Trash, disrupting animal habitats, feeding wild animals, and unattended campfires leading to forest fires are some of these negatives. Also, some scenic land must be sacrificed for roads, parking lots, and often billboards. Oil, gas run off roads and parking lots onto the land and into our water. Other vehicles, boats and buse, pose the same threats.

Tourism fulfills a social need to connect to nature. People enjoy a number of recreational activities. Some tourists hunt, fish, play sports, snowboard, surf, or ski. Jetskis, snowmobiles, and speedboats are also popular. Some people find shopping a social experience. There are others who prefer a more passive appreciation of nature, sometimes called ecotourism. Ecotourists try not to disturb nature—just observe it through camping, biking, hiking, photography, and bird watching. Whatever the way people choose to enjoy a landscape, the social experience may just promote enough interest in a landscape that people will be committed to solving some of the ecological problems caused by tourism.

The Balance
Tourism lets people make a living and fulfill our social need to connect with nature. But tourism can also have a hefty toll on a landscape’s ecology. The decisions we make about solving and avoiding environmental problems will determine whether tourism and landscapes share a working relationship. Attention to these problems will help to strike a balance between the economic, ecological, and social aspects that lead to a working landscape.

What do you think?
How should tourism be part of a working landscape?



Explore More: Working Landscapes
Copyright 2004, Iowa Public Television
The Explore More project is supported by funds from the
Roy J. Carver Charitable Trust
and the USDE Star Schools Program.




Tourism in the Loess Hills
For thousands of years before European settlement, prairie covered 80% of Iowa. This prairie provided habitat for 250-300 species. Today only 0.1% of the state's original 28.6 million acres is estimated to remain prairie.

Should the Loess Hills Become a National Park?
Have you ever visited a national park—maybe the Grand Canyon or Mammoth Caves? These publicly owned areas are certainly unique and worth seeing. More

Tourism in Branson, Missouri
The Ozark Mountains are some of the oldest in North America. They are located in southern Missouri and northern Arkansas. Branson is a small town in Missouri's Ozarks. Only 6,050 people call it home, but almost 7 million people visit each year! Why? More

PBS NewsHour Online Links

The White River National Forest, located in central Colorado, is used by over 12 million visitors a day. And by 2020, it may see 20 million visitors per day. A new plan on land use is being looked at by the Forest Service. It would limit motorized vehicles, mountain bikes, and skiing developments. Some people are happy with the plan. Others are just plain mad.

In the southeast United States, states like Tennessee are having issues with logging. Some loggers have switched from selective logging—cutting down the largest and most valuable trees—to clear cutting entire areas. Here what outdoor enthusiasts, property owners, loggers, and local politicians have to say about it.

Missouri's South Grand River, once a river of recreation and picnics, is now clogged by five logjams and trash (tires, plastic, appliances). The farmland alongside the river floods every year. It seems like everyone's hands are tied and no one can doing anything about it.

Web Site Links
Waubonsie State Park
This park sits in the Loess Hills. Check out what there is to do at Waubonsie State Park and view a map.

The National Scenic Byways Program
Under the National Scenic Byways Program, the U.S. Secretary of Transportation recognizes certain roads as National Scenic Byways or All-American Roads based on their archaeological, cultural, historic, natural, recreational, and scenic qualities. There are 72 such designated byways in 32 states. The Loess Hills Scenic Byway is one of two in Iowa.

Loess Hills Hospitality Association
This group promotes tourism in the Loess Hills. They offer bus tours, suggestions of places to visit, and a history of the area.

Environmental Protection Agency
Pollution Prevention and Environmental Impact Reduction Checklist for Recreation and Tourism. This site looks at how tourism and recreation affect the environment.

Oregon Live (The Oregonian)
"Watercraft pollution may lead to new rules" is an article about the polluting power of two-cycle engines. These types of engines are found in many lawn mowers, personal watercraft (jetskis), and snow blowers.

World Tourism Organization (WTO)
The WTO is a global tourism organization that has proclaimed 2002 the International Year of Ecotourism. Search this site for a global perspective of what ecotourism is all about.